So here’s my final breakdown of all 5 box companies.
| Company | Cost (w/out coupon) | Coupon | Tailored | Item | Items Worth | Dog happiness | Human happiness |
| Pets Love Toys | $25 | none | You pick what comes in the box, Tailored by dog weight | Toys and Treat/Chews | $30+ | + + + + + | + + + + + |
| Bugsy’s Box | $29 (CAD) | none | One dog size only | Toys and Treat/Chews | $30+ | + + + | + |
| Spoiled Rotten | $25 | available | One dog size only | Toy, treats, accessory, suppliment | $40+ | + + + + + | + + + + |
| Pawalla | $20-$30 | available | Two box sizes, Pet products tailored with profile | Can foods, treat, suppliment, accessory | $30+ | + + + | + + |
| BarkBox | $29 | available | Pet products tailored by weight | Toy and Treats/Chews | $35+ | + + + + | + + + + |
IN THE END:
Pets Love Toys- Pros: I knew exactly what Eclair would like and picked my favorite box from the show room / Cons: There is no surprise factor when the box comes.
Bugsy’s Box- Pros: Treats were interesting, very cute company name. / Cons: Credit card fees apply to USA residents (generally). No treats and toys caterred to your dog’s size or condition.
Spoiled Rotten- Pros: Varied items and great price worth more than box. / Cons: Items are all from their PetFlow website, don’t expect unique niche-like biscuits that’s aren’t mass produced.
Pawalla- Pros: Pet nutritionist picks the stuff, so expected food items are all high quality. / Cons: Pet nutritionist picks the stuff, so don’t expect toys to be stimulating.
BarkBox- Pros: Unique food items and sure please-rs to dogs. / Cons: Least amount of items compared to other boxes. If you’re looking for quantity, pass this box by.
The Winning Box, I leave it to you and your pooch to decide. As all dogs are made differently, perhaps things Eclair and I didn’t like you would. I just place before you what I honestly thought about each box.